The CW Source

Chloe/Jimmy

From
"maybe it's a giant fluke just like this relationship"

to

"marrying you was the biggest mistake of my life"

And people try to convince me that Jimmy cares about Chloe? Puleese. Whenever they're together they have to be lesser of who they really are. It never worked for either of them

It's SO OVBIOUS that Chloe/Jimmy breakup scene was going to win.This scene really made me cry and I stil crying when I see it again,It was so so real that everybody feels it,I like OTH too but the Lucas/Peyton scene was actually like seeing a silly breakup scene,I didn't feel it,besides the song was a little more fast than the original,besides Smallville uses this song before OTH,They shoot this scene in August so they won the song first.

um, I never understood the whole chloe being with jimmy in the first place, where is the chemistry? oth should win seriously. I love smallville too since day 1, but jimmy and chloe just dont do anything for me whatsoever.

I vote OTH i am a die hard leyton fan and that scene make me cry everytime i see it ...iT's just the best and sadest scene i have ever seen on tv !

GO LEYTON !

I voted for the One Tree Hill breakup all the way

I don't like Leyton at all, but that scene was just wonderful. I mean, I was angry at Peyton a little bit, but also glad because they broke up. Plus, it was just awful, looking at Lucas' face, you could see the heartbreak all over it. Although not as much as episode 307 when he saw that Brooke slept with Chris.....

I don't know, it might just be me, but that scene only made it for me because I just died when I saw his face...:(

chloe is hot and smart! She is the only reason why I watch Smallville!

Smallville all the way!! I just watched the break up clips, and they all were not that good(except for smallville) Chloe & jimmy's break up was the most saddest and realistic.. Not couting the recent break up between Lana & Clark..(: SMALLVILLE RULZ!!!

That Chloe chick looks more like a 6 year old
haha.

chloe and jimmy! oth one was....errr...okay. but this thing between peyton and lucas was the thing dragged on too long.

did you see chloe's face at the end?? heeeaaartbreaking. i'm not even a smallville fan.

Smallville are such copycats.
I have no idea how they're winning ;their scene didnt even come close to having tears in my eyes.

OTH FTW.
:P
TAKE THAT SV FANS.

Missy Higgins song "Where I stood" is really sad and beautiful. I knew the song from Smallville but not from OTH. : )

omg, how can u not vote 4 oth, i m not a big fan of leyton, but i think the breakup scene was so heartbreaking!!!! come on oth fans!!! don't let smallville win!!!

If only Chloe and Jimmy had STAYED broken up...

Chloe/Jimmy was a perfect break up scene. The only bad thing is that they got back together!

Come on guys. The Lucas/Peyton break up was THE SADDEST THING I HAVE EVER SEEN. How is the Chloe/Jimmy scene winning?!

the Aliens in America one was lame, the Gossip Girls break up was kind of boring, teh OTH one was sad but too romantic to be a real breakup.

The Smallville one was the only one that felt like a true breakup so I voted for that. It was emotional and sad and you knew what was coming next but hated it 9cause they're so cute together). Breakups are painful and the Chloe/Jimmy one was that.

yea pretty sure the winner here is missy higgins!!
b/c she rocks! and CLEARLY writes the BEST break-up songs ever!! lol

but def down w/ OTH --even tho im not so much an l/p fan, that scene will make any1 sad i think!

Leyton broke my heart in 505. There was so much beauty and pain in that scene, and in the following scene when Lucas left her in the hotel room. These two have never needed words to portray true love and heartbreak that never fades. The beauty of LP is in what they don't say. That's one of the many reasons that I love them.

oth is very nice.. very sad.. i vote for oth

It wasnt sad at all to watch Lucas and Peyton Break up, that was actually awesome! hahaha

the oth breakup scene was RUBBISH. it just didn't make any sense.

Big Leyton fan. Not a fan of how Lucas treated Peyton this season, but that was heartbreaking.

Come on One Tree Hill fans. How can you not vote for the Leyton breakup. It is SO sad.

chloe/jimmi was the most realistic and the saddest!!

oth&gg i-love-you-but-i-can't-be-with-you-so-i'm-with-someone-else-but-i-wanna-be-with-you sagas are boooooooriiiiiing!!!

... and world domination to follow.

well one tree hill wins for best song! haha until smallville used it too!!!
well yay for MISSY HIGGINS!! i guess she should just win! lol lol

I vote Nate & Blair!

Although I knew they broke up before the flashback of the breakup aired, I was SO HAPPY with Lucas & Peyton's breakup!

Oh my god! Lana's break-up KILLED me...and I was one that was sick of them by that point too.

Katie I was thinking the same thing... LOL LP's breakup was tear worthy and definitly my pick.

Nate and Blair, i cant's stand leyton so i was happy when they broke up, but i was soooooo sad when brucas broke up, it made me cry.

Chloe and Jimmy! That was so sad, there was actually tears and that's why it's the best breakup scene.

No Clark/Lana? The taped goodbye broke my heart.

Chloe and Jimmy, that was so sad!!!!!

I found the Nate/Blair breakup sad and I also found Chloe/Jimmy's sad also but NOTHING beats the Lucas/Peyton breakup. It was the saddest breakup I have scene on TV this year, and I'm not even that big of a leyton fan. To tell you the truth I will always love Brucas a little more, but I still cry EVERY time I see this scene.

Who knew Missy Higgins song was so popular for Break Up Scenes with The CW!!

OTH all the way. That was such a sad scene. I bawled my eyes out!

WOW. oth and smallville used the same song in the break up scenes...

haha :D